3 Reasons Why Generation Y Won’t Kill The Book Industry

February 9, 2009

books, bookshelf

The #1 habit successful people share with me is this: They read books to learn.
– Seth Godin

Like many people, books and I didn’t get along too well in school. Books were essentially assignments and that meant deadlines, responsibilities, and ultimately judgement. When I performed poorly on reports I came to the conclusion that my teachers didn’t understand my style of writing. The unimpressive grades rolled in and instead of blaming my abilities I blamed the defenseless books. Later I learned that there were rules and structure that you had to play by. In this way writing became a game and in return this game generated my respect for authors and for books.

One misconception of my generation is that we don’t read books. In fact, much like the newspaper and music industries, the publishing industry is heading down a slippery slope and all fingers keep pointing to this “new generation” of blog-crazed young adults. Here are three reasons why it is not our generation’s fault that the book and publishing industry is in turmoil.

1. Blame old people not us.

Publishers are currently embracing and blaming new mediums like audio and ebooks for their downfalls. Unsurprisingly, unit sales are high but margins are too low to compensate for the decline in their printed counterparts. Products like Amazon’s Kindle and the Sony e-reader are undoubtedly gaining market share and interest but is it really from the tech savvy “millenials”? Studies are sparse but taking a look at this Amazon Kindle forum clearly shows that the facebook and ebook generations are decades apart.

2. Old school is new school.

Last year could have been mistaken for a film-noir homage to argyle sweaters, aviator glasses, and the cultural influences of the 40s and 50s. The year even saw an 89% rise in vinyl record sales thanks to 1000s of purchases by 18-30 year olds (and Radiohead). I’ll go out on a limb and say that books also belong in this category of fashionable rebirths. Today’s young adults find just as much satisfaction in reading a paperback and displaying it on their bookshelf as their parents and grandparents once did.

3. Blame the authors not us.

seth godin, action figure

This last point is a slight exaggeration but let’s take Seth Godin as our unknowing case study. Seth is one of the most well respected marketers in the industry with a slew of popular books, a high traffic blog, and a number of public appearances under his belt. Most would think that his blog and appearances were merely supplemental, a marketing tool, to his books but he believes that less than 10% of his blog readers have read his published work.

Let’s put this another way: In the consumer’s eye, Seth’s brain droppings have multiple access points of equal importance and value. Seth’s blog is updated daily and his musings can be seen and heard with a quick search on YouTube. The ease of the web makes it almost too easy to avoid reading his books and end up with the same understanding of his theories. (I still recommend reading his books even if it’s just for the case studies)

You could substitute Seth for Tim Ferriss, Chris Anderson, or Malcolm Gladwell and arrive at the same conclusion. Oh and by the way, Tim is the only person on that list who could possibly be considered a “millenial” out of this group.

So stop using Generation Y as a default, catch all, pointy-finger-receiving, excuse for why an industry is no longer thriving!

  • TwitThis
  • StumbleUpon
  • Digg
  • Facebook
  • del.icio.us
  • Technorati
  • E-mail this story to a friend!
  • Hello, I was lead here by your post on 'On My Bookshelf on Twenty Something Bloggers'. I have to agree with you, it isn't our fault the book industry is on the verge of failing. Older people always assume that the younger generations simply don't read, which just isn't true. I personally have millions of books, I read all the time, both for school and personal pleasure, and I know tons of ' young' people who read.This passion for books could be directly linked to my dreams of becoming a novelist .
    I'm sick of our generations being the scapegoat for all things that go wrong. If they are looking for someone to blame they should put the blame on the guy who gave Paris Hilton a book deal!
  • The scapegoat route and the amount of negative/apathetic labels we receive is becoming trite. We've created movements with green energy, elections, and even are at the front lines of a war that all of us didn't agree too and was decided by an older generation.

    And you're absolutely right - there might be a select few of us who are fueling the success of reality tv shows and these faux-lebrities like Paris but it's the 40 - 50 year old marketers who are really behind the scenes. It's just pathetic.
  • hey, is this a snapshot of your bookshelf?? i have 3 of these books! Purple Cow, Blink and No Logo. Very cool!
  • Yep that's my shelf. I'm growing weary of these business/marketing books though. My favorite book of all time is actually missing from the shelf - Shantaram. It's surprising how much you can learn about management and business practices from novels.
  • As a soon-to-be university graduate, I can relate to the idea that books can feel more like work than pleasure. But there was a time, before university, when I really enjoyed reading books and I read a lot of them. Today, I have dozens of books I still haven't read, partly due to lack of interest but mostly because I haven't had the time to read books for pleasure. But I hope to read them one day soon.

    Most Gen Yers I know read quite a few books and are less likely than older generations to go to a used book store or library to get them. There's something about a brand new book in your hands and in your bookshelf that feels so good.
  • You're so right... there is something about the feel of a new book that in some strange way makes me feel smarter. Maybe my years of frustration with reading was due to the smell of a senior citizen home that emanated from the books in the library.

    Good luck with the book collection!
  • Hello Rikin - I stumbled across your blog this morning and this post in particular jumped out to me. 'Reading' in general has a negative connotation with the vast majority of our generation. As you state in your post here,

    'Books were essentially assignments and that meant deadlines, responsibilities, and ultimately judgment'.

    It has taken me a while, and I am still only in the beginning stages of actually enjoying reading. I associate books with the required reading from the college days and am only beginning to realize the knowledge and insight that can be absorbed from reading books. Yes, the internet is an amazing source of virtually unlimited information, but there is still something to be said for getting away from technology a little and sitting down with a paperback.

    Good thoughts - I encourage you to swing by my blog: www.lifewithoutpants.com. I'll be sure to become a regular here.
  • Matt - You've hit the nail on the head... breaking the association between books and required reading is a task in and of itself. In fact, after years of being forced to read "business" books as part of my studies I now find them pretty trite and obvious. Right now I'm reading 'Outliers' and other than a few good case I could have told you that 'timing is everything' or it's all about ' time and place'.

    Anyways... checked out your site and it really is a good read... subscribed to your RSS too. Goosebump readers must always stick together.
  • Thanks for coming by my neck of the woods rikin - I have subscribed here as well and added a link to your blog on my sidebar, good for us bloggers to stick together! And you've got to love some throwback R.L. Stine novels!

    It really is a daunting task breaking the association between reading as a chore and reading for enjoyment. I am still in the beginning stages of that 'book' thought process development - but I have read a lot of interesting stuff lately, 'Sex, Drugs, and Cocoa Puffs', 'Oryx and Crake', 'A Culture of Fear' - I'm definitely interested in books that tackle sociological or philosophical ideas, mixing in pop culture and current events.

  • I love books and have bookcases full of them. I read a lot of books because they cover subjects in great depth that simply cannot be done adequately in an online format. However, without question, I now do a lot more reading online. I can consume a lot wider variety of material a lot faster that way. I don't think I'll ever give up my books though. I have a kindle and I love it. But I still buy a ton of paper books.
  • The internet really has facilitated mass consumption of information but there should also be a healthy dose of output as well as input.
blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: