Advice On Choosing a Major

July 9, 2009

I made a big mistake. As a highschool student I knew that I wanted to be a marketer. I wasn’t a fan of medicine, science, law, and I even knew that I didn’t want to do finance or accounting. Marketing felt like a natural choice to me because it seemed to be the perfect balance of business savvy and creativity so choosing it as a major seemed like a no brainer. I then went on to take four years of courses on advertising, research, statistics, and held a number of great marketing internships. Today, two years after my graduation, I realize that my decision to major in marketing was a mistake.

Marketing came naturally to me. I had always been fascinated with molding a brands message. I would see ads on TV and instantly come up with criticisms and think of ways to make them more effective. The Internet was another area that I was extremely comfortable with and I felt this intrinsic knowledge of which sites were working and which were simply poor imitations or shots in the dark. I had a sense for navigation and UI and could easily flip the switch from talking to geeky coders to everyday users. I did very well in college and graduated with top honors in my class. Looking back now I see that success was actually a sign of a problem. Although I worked hard for my grades it may have also been that I was simply good at that subject and not challenging myself enough. I was a born marketer and didn’t need to study it – what I lacked were tangible skills to supplement my marketing skills.

My mistake was choosing to focus on something that I was good at, and could probably perfect through experience rather than textbooks, instead of honing skills that could reinforce and supplement my core passion. In retrospect, I should have studied computer science or even graphic design – I was interested in both before college as well. If you’re reading this and are in a position to start your studies fresh I suggest you take a good look at what you know you’re good at and then focus on everything else. Aspire to be a one-man powerhouse not a one-trick-pony in what ever profession you choose.

I Blame The System

Some colleges and universities are very good at allowing you the freedom and flexibility to cover different topics as you work towards graduation. Mine was not and many others simply fail to create a curriculum tailored around student interests. Instead there are asinine rules in place that waste everyone’s time, energy, and motivation. Especially motivation. Most of this wastage comes in the form of required electives like two courses in the sciences and three in liberal arts. I remember taking a class on dinosaurs one semester because I had no interest in learning physics or chemistry further than a highschool level. My time spent learning about the Mesozoic Era would have been better spent in an intro to typography or photoshop class. Steve Jobs once said that after he dropped out of college he was able to drop-in on the classes he was interested in. It was in a calligraphy class that he snuck into where he gained respect for typesetting which he eventually applied to Apple’s first operating system.

The education system is flawed and so is recruitment. These rules and exams all trickle up to companies who simply don’t know how to find the best candidates for each position without relying on standards that were based on the aformentioned asinine practices. It’s a real shame.

  • TwitThis
  • StumbleUpon
  • Digg
  • Facebook
  • del.icio.us
  • Technorati
  • E-mail this story to a friend!
  • I agree with you on this subject to a certain extent. I think that universities spend too much time keeping students separated into small majors and classes with no mixing of those in different majors. The fact that someone who studied marketing didn't get a photoshop class is unsettling. I studied engineering and heard through the grapevine that I was able to forgo learning about ancient art history and instead take a class in Photoshop and Flash that counted towards the same art credits. I guarantee that I had much more fun in the Flash class than I would have in the former.

    However, I think that the advice to tell people to study one of their weaknesses could have two major problems. It is possible that they will not be able to excel at their weakness major the same way that they were able to if they had chosen what they are good at. This would then lower their GPA and place them at the bottom of the list when it comes to get a job. Secondly, if the weakness major was pursued and a year later they found out they should have been doing what they were good at all along, then there is a year of tuition almost wasted on a major they will not continue to pursue.
  • I agree Ben, it's definitely a difficult choice and one that could have some serious repercussions. If a school offers the flexibility I discussed I would definitely opt for that. For example, a double major in Marketing and Design would have been perfect but unfortunately unattainable for me. If a school doesn't offer that opportunity then I guess there's the guaranteed way to a good GPA and there's the difficult more risky way of challenging yourself but potentially receiving a low GPA but could have a very high payout. Again, you'd be a force mejeure.

    I think the fact that schools don't make it easy to create your own curriculum and neither schools nor companies reward those who take this type of risk is a big issue. One that I hope is being tackled.
  • The more important question on choosing a major...why do we expect people to go from having Mom wash their soccer gear and teachers granting "extra credit" in June to being on their own and deciding what to do for the next 40 years or so when most don't even know who they are? That's why we have so many non-trad students and mid-life crisis career reassessments. What we are good at and "seems like a good idea" straight out of high school is not always the life that we would have chosen had we known then what we know now. I wonder sometimes "what would have been" if I had taken time off between, though I'd be worried I wouldn't have gone.
  • I was actually thinking something similar but I was wondering what it
    would have been like if I had a little bit of real world experience
    like an internship BEFORE deciding a major. Sometimes I even think
    the idea of apprenticeship should some how be incorporated into higher-
    education to ensure that we're choosing the right industries and
    careers for us.

    I agree the jump from high school to college is pretty drastic but I
    enjoyed that jump because it brought an added excitement to the
    experience.
blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: